Skip to content
Taletranscendence-pt-3

Transcendence (A Deer College Romance) Pt 3: Introduction to Comparative Religion

Rating
+16
Author
XHAWK77X
Filed
Last revised
Revisions
3
Length
4,077 words · 18 min
Contents & file data

After avoiding each other for as long as possible, Andrew and Oz are forced to attend Comparative Religion together.

Andrew

Andrew’s attempts to solve his Sarkic roommate problem failed, failed, and failed again.

The Dean of Students brought in a technician to try to fix the system. She couldn’t do a fucking thing. Andrew tracked down Stephane Carson and grilled her on what had happened when she defied the system. It was as bad as he feared. He paid a divination major one-hundred dollars to get her to try to find out why this was happening. She went into a trance, spouted some useless poem, then refused to give Andrew his money back.

On Sunday, he went back to his parents’ house and meticulously reassembled the computer he’d wanted to take to Deer. He’d spent hours taking it apart and packing it, and was now spending just as much time putting it back together. All that time wasted, thanks to the Sarkite.

“Why did you decide to move it back?” his mom asked.

Should he tell her? No. There was no point. If no one at Deer could do anything, she couldn’t either.

“It didn’t fit in the room,” Andrew said.

“Oh, I’m sorry to hear that.”

After reassembling the computer, Andrew spent several hours gaming on it. Now that it was stuck back at home, he’d have fewer chances to use it.

He didn’t return to Blackwood Hall until after midnight.

Six hours later, he woke up for his first class. Fighting to keep his eyes open, he rushed to the Student Union to get himself the largest coffee he could. From there, he barely made it to Computer Science.

At least the class itself went well. A few of the other freshmen from WAN For All were there, and the professor had some augmentations as well. After class, Andrew spoke to him about his trouble with the roommate-assignment system, but the professor didn’t think there was anything he could do. “The system is just like that sometimes,” he said.

“Please, can you at least look at it?”

“Is your roommate really that bad?”

Yes. He was. Of course he was. He was a godsdamned Sarkite.

Andrew couldn’t say that, though. The Flesh-weavers had most of this school convinced they were poor persecuted victims, and expressing “hatred” toward them, even to a fellow Mekhanite, could get Andrew in trouble.

Andrew already needed another coffee, but he couldn’t go get one without making himself late for Algebra. Only after that class did he go to the Student Union for lunch. There was a large food court there, which included an Ambrose, a Thai restaurant, a Burger King, a Starbucks, and a small deli in the Northeast corner, from which Andrew got a small salad sandwich.

After that, Astronomy, taught by a woman with a thick Mediterranean accent. On Wednesdays, Astronomy would be followed by a lab component, but not today. That meant his last class was over prior to 3:00 PM. From there, he went to Deer College’s Library and did most of his homework for today’s classes. By the time he returned to his dorm, Oz was already asleep.

Andrew’s earliest class the next morning was at 11:30, which gave him time to have breakfast in Blackwood Hall’s cafeteria. As he sat in the corner of the dining hall, he spotted the Sarkite on the other side of the large room. Andrew stared at him for a few seconds. Oz noticed, and met his gaze with the most hateful glare Andrew had ever seen.

“I shall walk by reason’s light,” Andrew whispered as he looked away.

From there, Andrew went to his English class. After that, lunch in the Student Union again, then Memetics, and then the class he’d been dreading. Comparative Religion. With the Sarkite.

Andrew was the first student to arrive.

In contrast to the forward-facing rows of desks in his STEM classes, the desks in this room were arranged in a U shape along the walls, covering three sides of the room, leaving one wall free to host the teacher’s desk, a whiteboard, and a projector.

No teacher, though. The only other living thing in the room was a small, creamy brown rabbit with black spots sitting on the instructor’s desk, dwarfed by the computer monitor next to it.

Where was Dr. Hopper?

Hopper.

Andrew took a moment to listen to his surroundings. There was no one close by. If he was wrong, there wouldn’t be anyone to mock him for it. “Dr. Hopper?” Andrew asked, looking at the rabbit.

“Yes indeed!” the rabbit said, voice full of energy. “Please, take a seat! I’m so glad to have you here!”

Andrew sat near the front of the classroom, in the chair closest to Dr. Hopper’s desk.

“Pleasure to meet you. I’m Dr. Cookie-Dough Hopper, and you are?”

“Andrew.”

“Well, it’s nice to meet you, Andrew. If you don’t mind me asking, am I correct in perceiving that your eyes are augmented?”

“They are,” Andrew said. “I’m a Maxwellist.”

“I’m happy to hear it,” Dr. Hopper said. “I always like to have a variety of religious perspectives in this class.”

Andrew nodded politely.

As far as he was concerned, this class was a waste of his time even without the Sarkite. He had nothing to gain from learning about Christianity or Judaism or Ortothanism. He didn’t necessarily have anything against them, but he already had a faith of his own. What did he need with more?

The next student to arrive was Sandra, the girl in the high-tech glasses from WAN For All. She and Andrew exchanged nods. After that, a small-figured pale boy in a red hoodie, then, a young man with bright green hair, then a blonde woman in short shorts and a green jacket, then a tall woman with olive skin and long, intricately-braided hair.

Next was Josh, the outsider who’d sat in on the WAN For All meeting. Josh waved at Andrew and Sandra when he spotted them. Andrew waved back.

Then came the Sarkite. Oz took a seat at the far end of the U-shape, which meant he was also near the front of the class, straight across from Andrew.

Several more students trickled in over the next few minutes. The last one to arrive was a muscular man with a large wooden cross around his neck. In all, there were twenty-four students.

“Welcome, everyone,” Dr. Hopper said, once everyone had settled in, “to Religion 100, Introduction to Comparative Religious Studies. I’m here to introduce all of you to a fascinating and crucially important area of study. For better and worse, religion has been a widespread element of the human, and, before that, sapient condition for as long as there has been intelligent life. Billions of years before this planet formed, the first Ortothans were practicing their faith in a primordial universe not yet host to native life.

“Now, I know this is a required course, and that, for some of you, that’s the only reason you’re here. If you’re not religious, or if you already have a confident religious perspective, you may think you don’t need to know about other religions. However, if I do my job, this class will help you understand why and how the nature of other faiths is relevant to you. The greatest wisdom is drawn from many places.

“Before we continue, let’s take a second to get to know each other. Give me your name, and, if you feel comfortable doing so, please share your majors and any religions you self-identify with. We’ll start here at the front. I’m Dr. Cookie-Dough Hopper. I was technically born twelve years ago, but I think of my real life as beginning two years later, when a thaumaturgy major gifted his pet rabbit with human intelligence as part of his thesis on augmentative enchantment. Like all lifeforms created or endowed with sapience as a result of official studies at Deer, I was given a full scholarship. I went on to major in a combination of Religion and Theology and ultimately receive a PhD in Religious Studies. I consider myself religiously eclectic. I dabble in Druidic, Pagan, Buddhist, and Ortothan practice, and I compliment my life with several forms of meditation.”

Dr. Hopper raised one paw and pointed it toward Andrew. “You?”

“I’m Andrew,” Andrew said. “I’m a Maxwellist here to study Computer Science and Paratech.”

They went around the room. The green-haired boy was Hunter. He was here to study Sociology and Thaumaturgy, and he had just been inducted as a fawn in the Order of the Sidereal Stag. Sandra introduced herself. Her Paratech specialization was unsurprising, but the fact that her mundane specialty was Medicine took Andrew by surprise.

It shouldn’t have. Most mechanical augmentations could only be installed by a qualified surgeon. It was a perfectly noble role for a servant of WAN to play.

The blonde woman in the green jacket was Maggie, a self-identified witch here to study Thaumaturgy. Next to her was Brad, no religion, studying Ontokinetics and Psychology. The pale boy in the red hoodie was Carter, an Ortothan studying Philosophy and Anart. The woman with the hair braids was Anna, another Sarkite, because the universe was too malevolent to inflict only one on Andrew. The boy wearing the wooden cross was Jack, a Christian studying History and Cryptozoology, with an emphasis on vampires.

“Because you want to hunt them or because you want to be one?” Oz asked.

“Hunt,” Jack said, tersely.

The rest of the class contained some Christians, a Reform Jew, a Norse Reconstructionist, and some nothing-in-particulars. The second-to-last one to introduce himself was Josh.

“I’m Josh,” he said. “Creative Writing. I haven’t picked my Occult Major yet. I’m… new to all of this. Like, magic and everything being real. I didn’t know about any of it until I got invited here. I was an atheist, back then. Now, well, I’m exploring.”

“Well, you’ve come to the right place to explore!” Dr. Hopper said.

Lastly, Oz. “Nälkän. Biochem and Carnomancy.”

“I see that you have a variety of religious perspectives,” Dr. Hopper said once everyone was done. “That’s exactly what I hope for with this class. Now, here’s where we’ll begin.” He hopped across the desk to the keyboard and pressed the spacebar with one of his paws. A slide appeared on the projector reading “What is Religion?” and below that, “What is a God?”

“What is religion?” Hopper asked. “What makes a belief system count as a ‘religion’ rather than a philosophy, an ideology, or a culture? In a world full of powerful, supernatural beings whose existence is indisputable, what makes some of them gods, and others just powerful mages or spirits? Do those distinctions even stand up to scrutiny? I’m going to go over some of the ways people have approached those questions, but, first, I’d like to hear from some of you.”

Oz’s hand went up. Dr. Hopper turned toward him, and his ears twitched. “Oz?” he asked.

“I can tell you exactly what makes a god a god,” he said.

“Bold,” Dr. Hopper said. “You should be careful being so confident about questions people have debated for millennia, but I’m nevertheless curious to hear your perspective.”

If Andrew got a nickel every time this rabbit used the word ‘perspective,’ he could afford all the cyberware he’d ever want.

Oz cleared his throat. “A god is a being that gets to tell everyone what to do.”

“What do you mean by that?” Dr. Hopper asked.

“Let me paint you a picture. It’s 2012. The Order of the Sidereal Stag has called an emergency meeting to solve the, somehow, very difficult problem of whether trans men should be allowed in their Order. There were pro and anti-trans factions and, and their disagreement was so fierce that they performed a ritual to summon the Sidereal Stag himself in order to settle the question.”

“Wait, you can do that?” Josh asked, his eyes rapidly shooting back and forth between Oz and Hunter.

“It’s not cheap or easy,” Hunter said, “but yes, this happened.”

Josh’s face was consumed by awe.

“For the record,” Hunter continued, “he sided against the transphobes.”

Oz nodded, “and anyone who didn’t accept his decision right then and there was expelled from the order. A few weeks later, those ex-members started talking about a new entity who had visited them. This other thing claimed to be the real Sidereal Stag and said the one who’d told them to fuck off was an imposter. He reassured them that he totally agreed with everything they believed.”

“Where are you going with this?” Hunter asked.

“Now, don’t get me wrong,” Oz continued. “Transphobia is stupid. The body is clay to be molded. However, putting aside the content of the argument, isn’t it a bit strange that the opinion of this one being was enough to settle such a large dispute?”

“It didn’t settle it, though,” Hunter said. “It just caused a schism.”

“But the Stag’s opinion held such overwhelming weight, even for the ones who disagreed with it, that they had to make up their own, new stag god who agreed with them. They couldn’t just disagree with the space deer. It had to secretly not be a real one, because even right after this entity sent them packing, they couldn’t imagine just having a different opinion than it. That’s what makes the Stag a god. Its followers view it as something to obey. It’s not even that powerful. There are reality benders with the same level of magical power, but because no one cares about praising and serving them, they aren’t gods. Now—”

“I see,” Dr. Hopper said. “So, moral authority. That is, indeed, a common trait people have assigned to gods. Anyone else have an idea they want to throw out, on the definition of a god, or of religion?”

Carter raised his hand, and Dr. Hopper called on him. “I think a god is just a really powerful being,” Carter said. “Pushing back on what Oz said, my god, Rakmou-leusan, isn’t some cosmic moral authority. He’s just a person who found a path to extraordinary power, which he uses to help people. I’m not his servant. I’m his ally.”

“And yet your value system is totally modeled off of him,” Oz countered.

“Is that really so ridiculous?” asked Andrew. “These are beings with incomprehensible knowledge and experience. Wouldn’t we expect them to know better than us most of the time?”

“That’s the logic of any authoritarian,” Oz said.

“I’m a bit confused,” Josh said. “Oz said he was religious too, right?”

“Nälkä has a different relationship with divinity than other religions,” Oz said. “We have a god, but we don’t serve her. We steal her power, like parasites. Our ultimate goal is to kill her and liberate mankind from her rule.”

“Your value system is still modeled after an authority figure,” Andrew said. “It’s just a prophet instead of a god.”

“Exactly. He’s not the source of morality. He’s just a guy with some good ideas. I can, and sometimes do, disagree with him. If your broken god said something horrible or ridiculous, would you be allowed to disagree with her?”

“She wouldn’t—”

“That’s what I thought you’d say,” Oz said.

“Let me finish,” Andrew said. “WAN’s greatest teaching is the value of reason. If I encountered evidence against a Maxwellist teaching, I’d be required to follow that evidence wherever it led, all dogma be damned.”

“And how often does that happen?” Oz asked.

“Never. Again, is it really so surprising that beings with vast knowledge and power aren’t wrong very often? And it’s not like these beings haven’t done anything to earn our respect. You say you hate Yaldaboth. Well, WAN is the one who imprisoned her.”

“Rakmou-leusan defends the universe from destruction,” Carter added.

“The Stag teaches his followers how to protect themselves and each other,” Hunter added.

Over the next minute, the class’s representatives of various religions made similar statements. Thor was a protective presence. G-d authored a covenant and honored it for thousands of years. The Serpent offered humanity knowledge, and, of course, Jesus died for humanity’s sins.

“Loads of people are self-sacrificing or have accomplished impressive things,” Oz said. “Most of them don’t ask us to see them as gods. You really think you can trust something that demands you never question it?”

“No one said anything about never questioning,” Andrew said. “You can retain your own judgement while still respecting people who have proven themselves to be wise and powerful.”

Several of the other students nodded or mumbled in agreement.

Andrew smiled.

“Alright!” Hopper said, “thank you for sharing. Andrew just gave us two more traits associated with godhood: wisdom and power. Does anyone else have ideas about what makes a god a god? Let’s hear from people who haven’t spoken yet.”


Oz

Oz clenched his fist. Of course the Mekhanite’s opinions would be more popular than his.

In the back of his mind, his mother’s words echoed. It would drive me mad to live amongst the weak, to be forced to respect those I should view as prey.

Other students offered more traits associated with divinity. Jack noted that many gods played a significant role in the creation of the world. Maggie suggested patronage over a specific concept, though the Ortothan noted that the Koru-teusa didn’t meet either of these requirements. It’s almost as if Oz was right about none of that being what mattered.

From there, they had a similar discussion about what made a belief system a religion. Jack argued that religion was defined by its social function. It was a belief system around which one organized one’s life. That triggered one of the other Christians to start talking about religion being a universal human need. The phrase “God-shaped hole” was used liberally. Josh pushed back on that, arguing that he’d been content as an atheist for years, but another student responded that Josh’s eagerness to explore anomalous religions once he learned of them proved that he, too, possessed such a hole.

Oz kept hoping for someone to make a joke about Alagadda, the only thing with an actual god-shaped hole in its heart, but no one did.

Hopper cut the discussion there. He turned back to his slide show, where he stated that most academics defaulted to self-ID in defining a religion. A social institution or belief system is a religion if it views itself as one. Otherwise, it’s not.

“I know we’re close to time,” Hopper said, “but before we end, I want to talk about one of your most important assignments. During mid-terms, you’re going to give an oral presentation comparing two religions of your choice. These can be two extremely different faiths or closely related ones, including sects of the same religion, as long as there are enough differences for you to say something interesting. Also, I’d prefer it if no two students picked the exact same pair of religions. Having one religion in common is fine, but not both. For that reason, you might want to figure out your topic sooner rather than later.”

A few of the students were able to pick a pair of religions right away. Jack wanted to do Christianity and some vampire cult no one had ever heard of. A few other easy pairs, including Christianity and Islam and Buddhism and Hinduism were also snatched up. Oz expected someone to take Mekhanism and Nälkä. Who could resist such a juicy rivalry?

The whole class could, apparently. No one even mentioned it.

Wait a second, Oz could use that.

He looked at the Mekhanite.

Tin-head thought he was the most rational thing on earth, and after ‘winning,’ the discussion they’d just had, he seemed to have the class’s respect.

Oz knew better. He knew this idiot was hopelessly biased against Nälkä. He probably couldn’t talk about it for more than a few minutes without making that obvious to all the students he just impressed.

Once class was dismissed, Oz followed the Mekhanite out of the classroom.

Tin-head turned to face him. “What do you want?”

“To go to my dorm room,” Oz said. “This is my last class for the day.”

“No problem,” Andrew said. “I’ll find somewhere else to study.”

“Do you know what religions you’re going to present on?” Oz asked.

“Why the hell do you care?”

“I just want to make sure I don’t step on your toes,” Oz said with mocking sweetness. “I was thinking about doing the Mekhanite and Nälkän faiths. A lot of interesting comparisons to be made there.”

“I’m sure your presentation will be utterly intolerable. Hopefully I’ll catch a plague from you so I can miss it.”

Oz chuckled. “You know, not everyone’s so emotional about the feud between our religions. Some of us are capable of impartiality.”

“My emotions have no control over me!” the Mekhanite said, barely stopping himself from shouting.

“You really think you could give an impartial presentation comparing our faiths?”

“Of course I could,” Andrew said. “I worship a god of reason. I am perfectly capable of remaining open-minded and impartial in my examination of any topic.”

“C’mon, man. You can’t even stand sharing a room with me. You think you could analyze Nälkä fairly?”

Andrew glanced around the hall. There was no one close enough to overhear him. “I detest your faith precisely because I understand it,” he said. “I could present a perfectly even-handed and factual analysis of it, with no bias present except the extensive sanitization necessary to describe your religion in diplomatic terms.”

“Prove it, then,” Oz said. “Go back to Dr. Hopper’s room right now and tell him that’s your topic.”

“Fine, I…” the Mekhanite hesitated. His eyes narrowed. “You’re trying to get me to do that,” he said. “What kind of trick are you pulling?”

Maybe he wasn’t quite as stupid as he seemed.

Still stupid, though. Stupid enough that all Oz had to do was play on his ego. “Well, if you were a bigoted moron, you saying something hateful in front of the entire class might be a wonderful way for you to get expelled. But that won’t be an issue, right? Dr. Cookie-Dough seems like a perfectly reasonable leporid. I’m sure he won’t punish you as long as your analysis is grounded in fact. Surely you wouldn’t have any trouble sticking to the facts, oh worshiper of reason?”

The Mekhanite clenched his fist. “This is a trap. I shouldn’t let you—”

“So, you admit you can’t do it?” Oz asked, flashing the widest, shit-eating grin he could. “You admit you hate my religion too much to analyze it objectively?”

“Of course not!” The Mekhanite said.

“Then prove it,” Oz said.

Andrew stared at Oz. He was practically shaking. That precious blood pressure of his was through the roof. “Fine,” Andrew said. “I will prove it, and when I do, you’ll see how revering WAN and her teachings has made me stronger than your silly tricks.”

The Mekhanite stomped back into Hopper’s room. Oz took a few paces closer so he could overhear their conversation.

“Oh, hello, Andrew,” Hopper said. “Is something wrong? You look—”

“I’m fine. It’s just occurred to me which religions I’d like to do my presentation on.”

“Oh?” Dr. Hopper asked.

“I’d like to compare Maxwellism with…”

Oz listened in delightful anticipation as Andrew’s mouth formed a word-initial S. Was this it? Was this the moment this idiot got himself expelled?

Alas, the gods were not good, and he remembered at the last moment “…Nälkä.” The word was awkward in his mouth, as if he didn’t quite view it as real.

Dr. Hopper sat there for a moment. “Okay,” he said. “I’m sure you’ll do a fine job.”

Oz couldn’t help but laugh.

No matter how hard this idiot tried to avoid slurs and use neutral language, his bone-deep hatred of Nälkä would seep into every word of his presentation.

If Oz was lucky, Tin-head would say something hateful enough to get himself in trouble. Even if he wasn’t, the Mekhanite would humiliate himself in front of the class and get a failing grade on the assignment.

Either outcome would be hilarious.

Referenced by

1 records
2 records