The Walls Are Thin
- Rating
- +4
- Author
- TboneBerryhill
- Filed
- Last revised
- Revisions
- 3
- Length
- 1,492 words · 7 min
Contents & file data
We moved into the house on Marigold Lane in the summer, when the days were long and the heat made the air shimmer like a bad memory. It was a fixer upper, my parents said. A “project.” What they meant was that it was cheap, and we were broke.
The neighborhood was the kind of place that felt paused. Lawns were mowed, but nobody was ever outside mowing them. Cars sat in driveways, tires half sunk into the asphalt like they hadn’t moved in years. The only sign of life was the old man across the street, Mr. Henderson, who sat on his porch from dawn until dusk, rocking in a chair that creaked loud enough to hear from our kitchen window.
He never waved. He just watched.
I was fifteen, too old to believe in monsters under the bed and too young to know that real monsters don’t hide in closets. They wave at you from across the street.
The first week was quiet. Unnervingly so. My little sister, Maya, who was seven, asked why the birds didn’t sing. I told her they were just shy. She accepted that, because she was seven and the world was still simple.
Then the moving truck arrived next door.
The house had been empty for as long as anyone could remember. The realtor had called it a “starter home,” which is what you call a place with a sagging roof and a basement that smells like wet pennies. But the new neighbors moved in overnight. Literally. We went to bed with an empty driveway and woke up to a U-Haul parked crookedly on the lawn, its back doors open like a mouth mid yawn.
I never saw them move anything in. No boxes. No furniture. Just the truck, and then, by noon, a man standing in the front yard.
He was tall. Too tall. The kind of tall that makes you tilt your head back a little too far, like looking up at a building. His skin was the color of old paper, and his smile was the first thing I noticed. It was wide. Too wide. It stretched past the corners of his mouth, like someone had drawn it on with a ruler and then pressed too hard.
He waved at me. I didn’t wave back.
“He seems nice,” my mom said that night at dinner. She hadn’t seen the smile. She’d been inside, unpacking plates.
“He’s weird,” I said.
“Don’t be rude, Eli.”
I let it go. But I started watching him from my bedroom window. He didn’t do anything. He just stood there, in the yard, facing our house. Sometimes he’d tilt his head, like a dog hearing a whistle. Sometimes he’d raise one hand and wave, slow and deliberate, even though I was behind glass and he couldn’t possibly see me.
That was the first thing that got under my skin. The second was the note.
It appeared on our front door three days later, tucked under the mat. The paper was soft, almost damp, and the handwriting was a child’s—looping and uneven, the letters too big for the lines.
“Come over for lemonade. Bring the little one.”
My mom thought it was sweet. “See? He’s just trying to be neighborly.” She sent me over with a plate of cookies and a forced smile.
I knocked. The door opened before my knuckles left the wood.
The man was standing in the doorway, filling it completely. Up close, his eyes were the worst part. They were the color of milk, and they didn’t move. They just stared, fixed on a point somewhere behind me, like he was looking at something I couldn’t see.
“You came,” he said. His voice was soft, almost a whisper, but it carried. “And you brought cookies. How thoughtful.”
He didn’t take the plate. He just stepped aside and gestured for me to come in.
The house smelled wrong. Like old flowers and something else—something sweet and rotten, like fruit left too long in the sun. The living room was empty. No furniture. No pictures. Just bare walls and a single folding chair in the center, facing the window.
“Where’s your stuff?” I asked.
“I travel light,” he said. He was still smiling. “Sit. I’ll get the lemonade.”
I didn’t sit. I stood by the door, ready to bolt. He disappeared into the kitchen, and I heard the clink of a pitcher, the rush of water. When he came back, he was holding two glasses. The liquid inside was yellow, but it was too thick. It clung to the sides of the glass like syrup.
“Drink,” he said.
“I’m not thirsty.”
His smile didn’t falter. “The little one. Maya. She likes lemonade, doesn’t she?”
My blood went cold. I hadn’t told him her name.
I ran. I didn’t look back. I just sprinted across the lawn and through my front door, slamming it behind me. My mom asked what was wrong. I told her I felt sick.
That night, I heard the creaking. Not from Mr. Henderson’s rocking chair across the street. From next door. The slow, rhythmic creak of a chair moving back and forth, back and forth, all night long.
The next morning, the note was on our door again.
“She has beautiful hair. Like sunshine.”
I didn’t tell my parents. They would have called the police, and the police would have found nothing. The man would have smiled his too wide smile and said he was just being friendly. And then he would have known that I was afraid.
Instead, I started locking my window. I started checking the doors twice before bed. I started watching Maya like a hawk, never letting her out of my sight.
But the man didn’t need to come inside. He was already in my head.
The third note came on a Thursday. It was tucked into Maya’s backpack, folded neatly between her crayons and her juice box.
“I can see you through the walls. The walls are thin.”
That was when I decided to do something about it. I waited until my parents were asleep, and then I snuck out. I crept across the lawn to the neighbor’s house, my heart pounding so loud I was sure it would wake the whole street. The front door was unlocked. It swung open at my touch, like it had been waiting for me.
The living room was the same as before—empty, except for the folding chair. But now there was a door at the back of the room that I hadn’t noticed before. It was painted the same color as the walls, almost invisible. I opened it.
Stairs led down into darkness. The air that rushed up was cold and smelled of damp earth and something metallic. I should have turned back. I should have run home and called the police and told them everything. But I was fifteen, and I was angry, and I wanted to see what was down there.
I descended the stairs.
The basement was a single room, lit by a bare bulb swinging gently from the ceiling. The walls were lined with shelves. And on the shelves were jars.
Hundreds of them.
Each jar was filled with a clear liquid, and inside each one was a small, pale object. At first, I thought they were stones. Then I looked closer.
They were teeth. Children’s teeth. Some still had bits of gum attached.
I stumbled backward, my hand flying to my mouth. The bulb swung faster, casting frantic shadows across the walls. And then I heard the creaking. Not from upstairs. From behind me.
I turned.
The man was standing on the stairs, blocking my only way out. His smile was wider than ever, stretching almost to his ears. And in his hand, he held a pair of pliers.
“You shouldn’t have come down here, Eli,” he said softly. “Now I have to take yours too.”
I don’t remember how I got out. I remember screaming. I remember the pliers glinting in the light. I remember the feeling of cold fingers around my ankle.
And then I was in my bed, gasping for air, my sheets soaked with sweat. It was morning. The sun was streaming through the window. Everything was normal.
Except for the taste in my mouth. Metallic. Like blood.
I ran to the bathroom and looked in the mirror. My teeth were all there. But they felt different. Loose. Like they didn’t belong to me anymore.
The man next door was gone by noon. The U-Haul was gone. The house was empty. Mr. Henderson was still on his porch, rocking, watching.
I never told anyone what I saw in that basement. Who would believe me? But sometimes, late at night, I hear the creaking. Not from the house next door. From my own closet.
And I know he’s still watching. Waiting.
Because the walls are thin.
And he can see right through them.
Referenced by
1 records- HubDecibelles2016+567