Skip to content
Talerush-delivery-contact

Rush Delivery Contact

Rating
+14
Author
Jiwoahn
Filed
Last revised
Revisions
2
Length
1,584 words · 7 min
Contents & file data

A Navy drill instructor waiting for a package is mysteriously injured, with crucial evidence ignored. Who, or what, attacked Petty Officer Hanahan?

crewtime 05/05/2026 (Thu) 17:54:00 #71221405


Good afternoon, Parawatch. This week's true crime story was suggested by cs1green, a US Navy service member who knew the victim personally and requested I cover his story, as the speed at which it was settled raised more questions than answers. When I looked into it, I found that crucial evidence was flat-out ignored — possibly to hide something that would damage the Navy's reputation.

The victim was Petty Officer First Class Patrick S. Hanahan, a Recruit Division Commander (RDC) for Recruit Training Command — the US Navy's boot camp in Great Lakes, Illinois. He enlisted in 2018 as a Logistics Specialist and was stationed in Yokosuka, Japan — a naval base only an hour south of Tokyo. He returned to the United States to begin his drill instruction duties only last year.

According to cs1green, Hanahan was well-liked among his fellow RDCs, although he was noted to have a "short fuse" that lasted well outside of work hours. As far as they could tell, Hanahan never expressed any suicidal ideations or suspicious behavior — such signals were always looked for by RDCs from their colleagues and the recruits in their care.

crewtime 05/05/2026 (Thu) 17:54:11 #71221406


On Thursday, October 16, 2025, Petty Officer Hanahan carpooled to work with a fellow RDC. The two entered the base at 4:52 AM — a typical arrival time, as Hanahan's division of all-male recruits had an early wakeup time of 5:30 AM to squeeze in the day's scheduled activities.

That morning, the two other RDCs in his division: Chief Petty Officer Antonio Jimenez and Petty Officer Second Class Scott Lehrmann, noted that Hanahan seemed "distant" and constantly checked his wristwatch. He was not even supposed to show up this early — he was only scheduled to take over the division at 2:00 PM.

All he talked about to his colleagues that day was the broken convertible hardtop motor in his 2000 Nissan Silvia Varietta — a car which he had brought with him from Japan using the Navy's program that allowed each sailor to import one car overseas, once, for free. According to Hanahan, the roof was stuck open — not ideal for the snowy winter season that was coming up. He also stated that he had managed to order a replacement motor, a very lucky find for the limited-production model.

At 7:15 AM, the division would depart for the "USS Chief" to learn firefighting skills. Hanahan stayed behind, promising to Jimenez and Lehrmann that he would catch up on some paperwork. This would be the last time he would speak to anyone in his division.

At an estimated 9:20 AM, Petty Officer Hanahan stumbles into a recruit compartment two rooms down from his own, holding his left hand to the back of his head to stop the bleeding. The scream of the recruits in the room alert Petty Officer Danielle Satterwhite and her colleague cs1green, who immediately call an ambulance as Hanahan loses consciousness.

Ultimately, he would not wake up. Despite the rush to get him to the nearby Captain James A. Lovell Federal Hospital, Hanahan would be declared dead at 2:50 PM from acute blood loss.

An autopsy conducted on Hanahan deduced that he had suffered a concussion, most likely from hitting the back of his head on a hard surface. The impact was enough to cause an internal hemorrhage that led to his death. There was also some bruising on his abdomen, suggesting he may have been punched or kicked in that area.

Due to the fact that a Navy RDC was injured in such a manner, the Naval Criminal Investigative Service (NCIS) immediately opened up an investigation.

crewtime 05/05/2026 (Thu) 17:54:36 #71221407


Unfortunately, the exact two timeline of events cannot fully be determined. The recruit barracks lack security cameras, ostensibly for the privacy of the recruits but usually led to "he said, he said" situations between recruits that were usually handled with entry-level separations.

The last person to see Hanahan alive was Petty Officer Finnegan Carino, who was the Officer Of the Deck (OOD) that day. Carino walked past Hanahan at an estimated 9:00 AM, merely exchanging "good mornings" between each other. He told investigators that Hanahan appeared "agitated" and was constantly staring at his watch, mumbling something about "a delivery", although Carino couldn't make out any specifics.

Notably, multiple RDCs recall hearing two "rumbling" noises during that time — one at around 9:10 AM and another at 9:15 AM. The rumbling was initially assumed to be from a recruit division getting their compartment "tossed" somewhere in the building, although cs1green did tell me it was a "very specific noise [he'd] never heard before, and hasn't heard since".

What is known is that Hanahan most likely visited the staff restroom before his death, as when NCIS inspected the room, they found a bloodstain on the restroom door — the blood matched Hanahan's. His Android phone had been smashed on the floor; no data could be recovered from it. The investigators noted the smell of smoke in the air, with an additional blood stain in the sink basin. Notably, the blood sample from the sink was not a match for Hanahan.

This single mismatch was the main crux for the suspicion that Hanahan was attacked in the staff bathroom by someone, although who that person was would stump investigators.

The main suspects were two recruits assigned to Hanahan's division: Donovan Stalheim and Logan Vasilus. According to Chief Jimenez and Petty Officer Learmann, both recruits had a poor personal history with Hanahan, with the latter often personally giving the two extra "instructional training" for their shortcomings.

Additionally, both of them stayed behind that day in the same building as Hanahan, offering a chance to enact revenge, especially for Vasilus, who was already being entry-level separated for a prior scuffle and was merely waiting for some paperwork to be completed before being transferred to Separations.

However, Stalheim was Sick In Quarters (SIQ) that day due to wisdom tooth surgery and was confined to his bunk. In fact, he was temporarily moved to Petty Officer Satterwhite's compartment, as SIQ recruits were not allowed to be alone by themselves when the whole division leaves for an activity. Satterwhite and cs1green both testified that Stalheim was in his bed the entire time during the incident, only waking up when the "rumbling" noise occurred.

That leaves Vasilus, who was idly waiting in the building's lobby, or "quarterdeck", to join the rest of the division for lunch. At first, it would've seemed possible for him to sneak off and confront Hanahan about his treatment of him, but Petty Officer Carino, whose OOD office had a window allowing him to see the entire quarterdeck, testified that Vasilus never left his sight, with the sole exception of his rove around the building where he met Hanahan for the last time.

There's also the fact that the sink blood sample did not match either of the two recruits. In fact, that sample did not match anyone in any US Navy database — recruit or RDC.

crewtime 05/05/2026 (Thu) 17:55:00 #71221408


NCIS closed their investigation into Petty Officer Hanahan's death only one week later. The only theory they offered was that Hanahan suffered from a freak accident in the staff restroom — while having a cigarette, he slipped on the wet floor and hit the back of his head on the door, causing a fatal concussion. No mention or explanation for the sink stain.

Of course, this didn't sit well with people who knew Hanahan, especially since he was an avid non-smoker — not mentioning the fact that smoking inside of the recruit barracks was strictly forbidden. cs1green argued that it was "highly unlikely" for the restroom floor to be wet enough to slip on, as he had used that restroom at an estimated 8:45 AM that day — the floor was, according to him, bone dry. There was also no blood stain in the sink.

The lingering question is why NCIS closed the case so quickly while seemingly disregarding clear evidence that would suggest an attack by another person. Was it to prevent further questions about how someone most likely unknown to the Navy could sneak into a restricted area full of future sailors and attack a drill instructor to the point of fatal injury, and then make a clean getaway?

I'd like to end with this: cs1green provided some extra evidence and shared a photo with me, although he requested that I refrain from posting the photo online.

On Tuesday, November 4th, 2025, a package with no return address arrived at Recruit Training Command addressed to "varietta0268", a username that was used by Hanahan on multiple websites. Of note was that the package was mailed to the specific recruit barracks Hanahan was working at when he died, a delivery address only used by recruits during their boot camp stay.

The package was opened by Chief Jimenez before being surrendered to NCIS, which is how cs1green and I were able to find out what was inside. The package contained a note reading, according to Jimenez:

Hope you're recovering OK. I'll be upfront about the fees next time. I hope this makes up for it, it's on the house!

The only other thing in the package was a brand new convertible hardtop motor for a Nissan Silvia Varietta.