Skip to content
Parawatch
Tale
news articleLevel 2 · RestrictedREC-1468910157

In Plain Sight

Author
aismallard
Filed
27 Jun 2026
Rating
+28
Length
1,403 words

crewtime 04/12/2020 (Sun) 22:43:29 #52793612


120 Broadway, as featured on a 1917 postcard.
120 Broadway, as featured on a 1917 postcard.

The Equitable Building in New York City is an easily overlooked but fascinating structure. It takes up an entire city block, and is one of a few dozen buildings in Manhattan which has its own ZIP code, 10271.

While New York's iconic skyscrapers feature setbacks which permit sunlight to reach pedestrians, the Equitable Building is effectively a large rectangular chunk of concrete: those walking nearby streets do so in darkness, even during daylight hours. Controversy over this aspect of its design culminated in the 1916 Zoning Resolution, the first municipal zoning code in the United States.

It is also the setting of lesser-known events, such as the unsolved murder of Mack G. Farrell.

On February 13th, 2018 at 8:17 AM, Mr. Farrell entered the building's lobby via its Wall Street Station connection and badged in. He took the elevator to floor 29A, where he worked as a graphic designer for a logistics company. Employees reported seeing him around from 8:30 AM to 2:00 PM, during which he enjoyed the daily catered lunch and discussed the recently-released film The Commuter with coworkers.

Around 1 PM, he received a message on his phone and excused himself. One coworker said he became "suddenly irritable", an unusual attitude for someone described as generally affable when not facing a deadline.

Cameras observed Farrell walking down the hall, seemingly on his way out of the building before pausing, checking his phone, and then angrily dipping into the office of the department head, Steve Wiertz. Farrell did in fact have a quarterly review meeting with Wiertz later that day, though the meeting was for 3:30 PM, more than two hours later. (Note that the office itself had no security cameras, so all surveillance information involving this office comes from the hallway camera instead.)

Meanwhile, Wiertz's assistant had stepped out of an executive meeting to retrieve some forgotten notes, and at 1:21 PM, was observed entering the office. She noticed Farrell, who said he was taking a phone call. In her interview with police, she explained that Farrell was alone in the room, pacing and clearly anxious. He did not appear to be in the middle of a phone conversation, but she brushed the inconsistency aside: apparently, their NY location was notorious for its chronic lack of available meeting rooms. Footage confirms her departing the room a minute later.

No other individuals were seen entering or leaving Wiertz's office until 1:37 PM, when an unidentified man entered. According to the report, he was described as "around 40", white, balding, and wearing a gray button-down coat. Later, two coworkers passed by the door at 1:55 PM, and said that they heard two men yelling at each other (though no words were audible).

Having finished their meeting, Steve Wiertz and his secretary entered his office at 3:07 PM, finding the corpse of Mack G. Farrell lying in a pool of his own blood. No other individuals were present in the room.

crewtime 04/12/2020 (Sun) 22:47:11 #52793770


Police on the scene identified signs of a struggle. Some papers had fallen off the desk, which itself had been pushed to the side. A metal filing cabinet was on the floor covered in blood. After forensic analysis, this was determined to be the murder weapon: someone had lifted it and thrown it at Mr. Farrell, who is believed to have died on impact. A search of his body yielded his keys and wallet (no cash is believed to have been removed). However, his cell phone was found near the door, completely pulverized. (Naturally, no data from it was recoverable.)

Additionally, the exterior window was broken, having been smashed from the inside. Inspection of the street and sidewalk outside found no fallen objects other than broken glass.

After police gained access to surveillance footage, investigation immediately turned to identifying and locating the man seen entering the office. Security in the building's lobby did not recognize his face, and there were no plausible ways for him to have exited the room after committing the murder. There were no outside stairs or ladders, no nearby ledges he could have reasonably climbed to, the window washer lifts were confirmed to have been locked down that day, and he certainly didn't jump down from 29 floors.

In fact, as far as I can determine, this mystery man does not appear on any surveillance footage anywhere in the building except for the hallway leading to the office and another hallway immediately prior to that one. It's like he appeared out of thin air in the interior fire stairs, walked to the office, had a loud argument with Farrell, killed him, then vanished.

crewtime 04/12/2020 (Sun) 22:51:50 #52793791


Besides the existence of a man who can seemingly turn invisible, there are a number of other details about this case that I found incredibly odd.

First, the murder weapon. The filing cabinet was noted to have weighed around 130 pounds (~59 kg), and I am seriously skeptical that your typical 40s-ish male could spontaneously lift such a heavy, bulky object, let alone wield it as some kind of weapon.

Next, the argument in the meeting room. The two witnesses repeatedly affirmed that, when they passed by, it only sounded like angry yelling between men and that it did not sound like a violent struggle or fight. If the man was some kind of assassin, then why did they first have an argument? If it was a fight that later escalated into a killing, then that suggests the two men knew each other… but how? Why at Farrell's place of work? Why does nobody in the victim's family seem to recognize the likely killer?

Then there is Farrell's behavior itself. He left lunch early, told the secretary he was taking a phone call despite this seeming to be a lie, was waiting in an office he knew would be empty for unclear reasons, and when someone entered, hung around long enough to allow for a filing cabinet to be thrown against his body.

As for the surveillance footage, the police ended up doing a fairly extensive check of all the footage from that day in their quest for the mystery suspect. While no men entering the fire stairwell remotely matched the description, one file mentions a short, heavy-set Chinese woman wearing a green jacket. She provided her ID (name "Yue Cheng") to a lobby worker in order to get a guest badge for floor 5, and while she was seen entering the stairwell, no other surveillance footage shows her exiting on any other connected floor. I can't find what time she is said to have arrived at the building.

Police did not investigate further, presumably due to her markedly different appearance from the suspect.

I also found one local news article discussing an unusual package sent to the victim's widow, Linda Farrell, on February 21st (about a week after the murder). The article simply called it an "apology letter" and said it contained ten thousand dollars in cash (currently held by police as evidence). I called the news office, and they provided me with the full text of the letter:

I'm truly sorry. I know I have anger issues, but I didn't mean to. I really didn't.

May Mack rest in peace.

crewtime 04/12/2020 (Sun) 22:56:03 #52793791


All of this is extremely unusual, but there is one final detail which I find truly inexplicable.

While the cause of death was recorded as blunt force trauma, police on scene also noted a set of massive, parallel lacerations across the victim's dress shirt and the chest underneath. The coroner noted in her report that, if this killing had occurred somewhere other than downtown Manhattan, that she would have believed that this injury was caused by a large mammal, such as a bear.

Even more bizarre, this detail seems to have corroboration: police found a witness who believes they saw the moment when the window was broken. They work in an office across the street from the Equitable Building, and had taken off their glasses to rub their eyes, when they saw a "big brown blur" seemingly punch through the 29th floor window. They raced to replace their glasses, but confessed that the only thing they saw clearly were some fragments of falling glass and a lone pigeon flying off, presumably startled by the noise.

news article · REC-1468910157End of document

Referenced by

23 records
  • Item fileRating +540

    SCP-5510Universal Remote

    Safeaismallard2020
    Safeaismallard2020+540
  • Item fileRating +331

    SCP-5900PITCHBLACK

    Pendingaismallard2020
    Pendingaismallard2020+331
  • Item fileRating +288

    SCP-3597Maladroit

    Euclidaismallard2019
    Euclidaismallard2019+288
  • Item fileRating +256

    SCP-4339The Attribute Pen

    Safeaismallard2018
    Safeaismallard2018+256
19 more