Skip to content
Item fileSeries 10neutralizedscp-9827

SCP-9827

The Grass is Always Greener

Object classNeutralized
Rating
+47
Filed
Last revised
Revisions
7
Length
549 words · 3 min
Contents & file data

on the other side

Item #: SCP-9827

Object Class: Neutralized

Special Containment Procedures: SCP-9827's remains are in storage. Research into the source of their former anomalous properties is ongoing.

Description: SCP-9827 were 10 duplicates of a man named Garrett Matney. All drowned on the same day (December 31st, 2025) in different locations. SCP-9827 only came to Foundation attention after its neutralization, when its 10 sets of remains were all separately identified as the same individual. Further investigation of Garrett Matney's lives found no physical or documented evidence of his existence after the year 2017, with the exception of its remains and objects that were on their person(s) at time of death. Despite this, each instance's life was partially remembered by 1-5 individuals that claimed to have been its friends or acquaintances.1 All known details of the instances' lives come from these fragmentary memories and objects found on their bodies, particularly the contents of their cell phones.

These details suggest that each instance was living a different lifestyle at its time of death, but that each of their personal histories diverged at different points from a similar past. It has been hypothesized that each instance originally inhabited a different parallel universe defined by the way its choices differed from those of other instances, and their remains were only displaced into this one postmortem. However, the partial memories of their acquaintances indicate that a more esoteric process may be responsible. There is no evidence that any instance was aware of or in contact with any others.

Designation Location Lifestyle
1 Richlands, Virginia inconsistently employed; incarcerated twice for drug possession and once for theft
2 Dunlap, Tennessee apprentice carpenter; regular at local cafe and game store
3 Huntsville, Alabama Ph.D. student at the University of Alabama in Huntsville
4 Durham, North Carolina pastor in the United Methodist Church; was engaged in an extramarital affair with a member of its church's congregation
5 Birmingham, Alabama delivery driver; active in local hardcore punk scene; member of a small anarchist activist group
6 Nashville, Tennessee semi-successful musician in a southern rock band, which broke up a month prior to its death
7 Gulfport, Mississippi fisherman; loner
8 Stennis Space Center, Mississippi member of the US Navy Special Warfare Combat Crewmen
9 New Orleans, Louisiana transgender woman; tour guide and aspiring author
10 New York, New York homeless; unemployed

It is likely that other instances existed, but were not detected by the Foundation because their bodies (if discovered at all) were never identified as Garrett Matney.

Addendum 1: Matney Parents

Messages saved to multiple instances' cell phones indicated that they had remained in contact with their parents, despite their obviously contradictory existences. In an attempt to understand how Mr. and Ms. Matney failed to notice the impossibility of their child's multiple simultaneous lives, they were interviewed by Foundation agents.

The Matneys reacted to questioning about their child with confusion, anger, and sadness. Their memories of Garrett are completely consistent with existing records, which agree that he drowned in a lake near Tazewell, Virginia in the summer of 2017.

His suicide note, like those of all ten SCP-9827 instances, contained the phrase "there has to be a better life".

Footnotes

  1. These individuals have since been amnestized, as the contradictory memories caused them considerable distress. ↩

Referenced by

2 records
  • Item fileRating +86

    SCP-9828The Scarlet Ichor

    KeterUncle Nicolini and Rez De Chaussee2026
    KeterUncle Nicolini and Rez De Chaussee2026+86